Discriminant function analysis in marine ecology: some oversights and their solutions
نویسندگان
چکیده
Marine ecologists commonly use discriminant function analysis (DFA) to evaluate the similarity of distinct populations and to classify individuals of unknown origin to known populations. However, investigators using DFA must account for (1) the possibility of correct classification due to chance alone, and (2) the influence of prior probabilities of group membership on classification results. A search of the recent otolith chemistry literature showed that these two concerns are some times ignored, so we used simulated data sets to explore the potential pitfalls of such oversights. We found that when estimating reclassification success for a training data set, small sample sizes or unbalanced sampling designs can produce remarkably high reclassification success rates by chance alone, especially when prior probabilities are estimated from sample size. When using a training data set to classify unknown individuals, maximum likelihood estimation of mixture proportions and group membership afforded up to 20 % improvement over DFA with uninformative priors when groups contributed to the sample unequally. Given these results, we recommend the use of (1) ran domization tests to estimate the probability that reclassification success is better than random, and (2) maximum likelihood estimation of mixture proportions in place of uninformative priors.
منابع مشابه
Dietary ecology of the Portunus segnis (Forskal, 1775) in the coastal waters of Hormozgan Province, Iran
In this study, the feeding habits of blue swimming crab (Portunus segnis) in the Northeast Persian Gulf were investigated. A total of 722 specimens were collected using bottom trawl. The samples were transferred to the laboratory in order to further analysis after freezing. All individuals were dissected and their stomach was removed. The results showed the vacancy index of stomach (CV) was 34....
متن کاملUsing Classic Discriminant Analysis and Detection Function for Separation of Chemical Victims in Sardasht City to Exposed and Non Exposure Mustard Groups in 2013 and Comparison with Logistic Regression
متن کامل
Investigation of morphometric variation and differentiation in common kilka (Clupeonella cultriventris) using factor analysis (PCA) and discriminant function analysis (DFA) in southern part of the Caspian Sea
This study was conducted to investigate morphometric variation and differentiation in common kilka (Clupeonella cultriventris) caught from Amir Abad and Babolsar fishing ports during winter 2013. Totally, 330 specimens (272 specimens from Amir Abad port and 58 specimens from Babolsar port) were caught by lift net and 30 absolute morphometric traits, 9 meristic traits, length and gonad, body wei...
متن کاملAn empirical study of innovation-performance linkage in the paper industry
To enter new markets and remain competitive in the existing markets, companies need to shift their focus from traditional means and ways to some innovative approaches. Though the paper industry in India has improved remarkably on its technological and environmental issues, yet it shows a low rate of innovation. The present paper attempts to review the industry in the perspecti...
متن کاملPinpointing the classifiers of English language writing ability: A discriminant function analysis approach
The major aim of this paper was to investigate the validity of language and intelligence factors for classifying Iranian English learners` writing performance. Iranian participants of the study took three tests for grammar, breadth, and depth of vocabulary, and two tests for verbal and narrative intelligence. They also produced a corpus of argumentative writ...
متن کامل